Automakers Call for Consumer Freedom
Canada’s electric vehicle (EV) mandates are under fire as leading voices in the automotive industry demand an end to federal sales requirements. Citing the termination of consumer EV incentives under the iZEV program and the lack of sufficient public charging infrastructure, automakers and dealers argue the government’s policy is out of touch with reality.
The mandates, introduced in 2023, were designed to push zero-emission vehicles (ZEVs) into the mainstream. Yet, without financial incentives or charging support, critics say the plan is falling apart. “Yesterday’s announcement by the federal government to halt all consumer incentives for zero-emission vehicles (ZEVs) comes at the same time as a slowdown in the buildout of public charging infrastructure. As a result of these developments, the federal government’s mandated ZEV sales targets are increasingly unrealistic and must end,” said Brian Kingston, President and CEO of the Canadian Vehicle Manufacturers’ Association.
“After all, no one would accept a one-size-fits-all housing policy.” AutomotiveWoman staff
It’s hard to argue with Kingston’s sentiment. Mandating Canadians to buy EVs without addressing their significant barriers—namely cost and infrastructure—is akin to mandating homebuyers to purchase condos without ensuring availability or affordability. Choosing a vehicle, much like choosing where to live, should remain an individual decision. Hybrid, plug-in hybrid, internal combustion engine (ICE), or fully electric—these options exist for a reason, and each suits different needs and lifestyles.
“If the government is going to mandate manufacturers to put ZEVs into the marketplace and pay severe penalties for not doing so, then government needs to ensure that it is doing its part to address key barriers to EV uptake—price and infrastructure,” added David Adams, President and CEO of Global Automakers of Canada.
The industry’s frustration extends to Parliament Hill, where stakeholders have voiced concerns over the government’s lack of foresight in securing the funding necessary for the EV transition. The situation is exacerbated by Quebec and British Columbia, provinces with their own mandates yet little consideration for the realities of consumer demand and infrastructure readiness.
Tim Reuss, President and CEO of the Canadian Automobile Dealers Association, criticized the federal government’s approach, calling it hypocritical. “The Liberal federal government has backed away from supporting the transition to electric vehicles, and now we are left with a completely unrealistic plan. There is hypocrisy in imposing ambitious ZEV mandates and penalties on consumers when the government is showing a clear lack of motivation and support for their own policy goals.”
Mandates might seem like a path toward a greener future, but without affordable EVs and widespread charging networks, they risk becoming an economic and environmental misstep. “While incentives are not required forever, they do need to remain in place until at least price parity has largely been achieved,” Adams argued. Without addressing the cost barrier, EV adoption will stall, leaving the federal government’s ZEV mandate targets in jeopardy.
Canada’s path to electrification should empower consumers with choices, not corner them into mandates. After all, no one would accept a one-size-fits-all housing policy. Why should cars be any different?
IMAGES: Canadian Automakers
Join the AutomotiveWoman community lifestyle newsletter: [email protected]
